Pumpkin Amaretto Cheesecake from Polly’s Slow Food in Saint Paul

563

Location:
Saint Paul, Minnesota

Status:
Permanently closed

Dates active:
1979-1989

Polly’s Slow Food served comfort food in Saint Paul for just over a decade. Owner Polly Sidney’s restaurant was the antithesis of the fast-food joints crowding out independent, sit-down eateries across the country. Polly’s Slow Food felt like you walked into a friend’s home for tasty, homemade food in a wholesome atmosphere.

The Early Years

Polly’s Slow Food first opened at 1589 S. Robert Street in 1979. The restaurant took over an old Texaco gas station and gave it a homey makeover. Cinnamon-colored wallpaper covered the walls, and vases filled with flowers were placed throughout the dining room to brighten the space. Polly and her father made the dining tables unique by collaging vintage postcards and old photos on the tops. It was then covered by thick plastic to make cleanup easy. Each collage featured a small photo of Polly — if customers could find it, they got a free slice of pie.

Polly designed the menu to give diners a break from the basic fast-food offerings that surrounded her restaurant. Classics like sandwiches, salads, and burgers were made to order based on the customer’s preferences. But it was the made-from-scratch meat pies, pasta, soups, and desserts that created a group of devoted customers. Fresh lahvosh – a traditional Armenian flatbread – was served with meals. 

A New Location

Polly’s needed a new place to call home within a couple of years. Around the same time, the former Northern Pacific Railway Company’s Como Shops were being converted into an enclosed shopping center named Bandana Square. 

Polly was the first tenant to sign a lease at Bandana Square in Saint Paul, giving her the pick of spaces. She chose a prime location with three rooms on the second floor. It had a view into the central part of the building with its original clerestory windows and timber trusses.

When the restaurant opened in its new location in November 1983, many loyal customers showed up to see Polly’s new digs. It wasn’t long before Polly’s reputation for delicious, seasonal food grew a faithful following in Energy Park. 

Polly’s weekly menu featured seasonal ingredients. The only item on the menu every day was the wine cheese soup. Polly’s mom, Ciel Bearth, was in charge of making the incredible pies offered each day. If one of Polly’s avid customers had a request, Polly added it to the menu for the following week. She let the customer know which day it would be on the menu and asked them to return on that day. 

Bandana Square Slumps, Polly’s Closes

Other than Polly’s, only a dozen or so shops and eateries had moved into Bandana Square in those early years. Polly’s and another popular restaurant, Filbert’s, were the main draw for the mall. By the end of the decade, the mall’s retail space was still only a little over half full. Rent was too high and traffic was too low, forcing several tenants out of business within a year or two. 

By the end of the 1980s, the Saint Paul Port Authority had taken over Bandana Square with the hopes of reimagining the mall into a success. For many tenants, redevelopment likely meant losing more money. Unfortunately, the uncertainty about what was to come caused several businesses to close their doors, including Polly’s Slow Food. 

After the closure, Polly directed operations and made wedding cakes for Buttercreme Desserts. Ciel joined her there creating desserts to be sold at Dayton’s store restaurants. Sadly, Polly passed away in November 2022 after a prolonged illness.

Pumpkin Amaretto Cheesecake

Served at Polly's Slow Food in Saint Paul, Minnesota.
Servings 16

Ingredients

Crust:

  • 2 cups graham cracker crumbs
  • ½ cup sugar
  • teaspoon cinnamon
  • teaspoon ginger
  • ½ cup butter, melted

Filling:

  • pound cream cheese, softened
  • 1⅓ cup sugar
  • 6 eggs
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • 2 cups canned pumpkin
  • 2 tablespoons light molasses
  • ½ cup amaretto
  • 1 teaspoon almond extract

Amaretto Whipped Cream:

  • 1 cup heavy cream
  • 1 tablespoon amaretto
  • powdered sugar (optional)

Instructions

  • In a bowl mix crumbs, sugar, cinnamon, ginger and melted butter. Pat mixture in the bottom and up the sides of a 9-inch springform pan; set aside. 
  • In a bowl beat cream cheese to soften, then beat in sugar until smooth. Add eggs slowly and continue beating. Blend in salt, pumpkin, molasses, Amaretto and almond extract; beat until smooth.
  • Pour mixture over crust in springform pan. Bake 1-1½ hours at 350°.
  • Turn off the oven and leave cheesecake in the oven for an hour without opening the oven door.
  • Remove cheesecake from the oven; let it cool completely and remove the outer ring of the pan.
  • Whip the cream and amaretto until almost stiff. Add a little powdered sugar to taste if you wish.
  • Serve each slice with a dollop of amaretto whip cream.
Close
History Hotdish © Copyright 2023. All rights reserved.
Close